The SNP won as they ran a good campaign and should be congratulated (but not emulated).


There is no shortage of people expressing opinions regarding why Labour lost the general election in Scotland.  These range from those on the left indulging in self-flagellation to those in the nationalist camp who want to rub salt in the wound.

Most overlook one key thing – the SNP won as they ran a good campaign and should be congratulated for it.  It had 3 key strengths which must be recognised.

Firstly, the SNP message relentlessly focussed on Nicola Sturgeon – her face was on every SNP billboard, leaflet and, unbelievably, even her executive helicopter. This was so overwhelming that there are stories abound of voters across Scotland believing she was standing in their constituency. This was powerful as most SNP candidates had no local standing.

Secondly, the SNP successfully portrayed Labour as a party who backed “£30 billion of Tory cuts”. This was complete bunkum, but it was repeated so often it stuck. Labour used the IFS to debunk this and the claim that the SNP could end austerity. Tellingly it failed because during the referendum debate Scots learned that for every expert opinion there is a counter opinion – and the SNP learned how to present both as having equal standing. This is a worrying development.

Similarly, despite Brown lifting 200,000 Scots pensioners out of poverty, the SNP portrayed Labour as a party that had done nothing for Scotland. Labour completely failed to refute this.

Thirdly, the SNP won because they kept their message simple. There were no complex arguments or IFS reports to contend with, just simple positive statements and phrases. I heard about one hustings where the candidates were asked to name their three top policies. The Labour candidate talked about tackling youth unemployment, ending foodbanks and implementing the living wage. The SNP candidate offered only three words: Stronger for Scotland.

So yes, Labour must reflect on this defeat. However, we all must also congratulate the SNP for a stunning victory.

2 thoughts on “The SNP won as they ran a good campaign and should be congratulated (but not emulated).

  1. james todd says:

    All good points, but there’s another one too. Labour has allowed itself to be pulled into identity politics, which the SNP is very happy to take part in. This election was about policy of course, but from what I can see that went as far as “SNP left wing, Labour right wing” without anything backing this up. But worse for Labour the SNP and its 100k members could gleefully set the election scene as pro-Indy parties pit against “Unionist” parties and Labour has walked right into this trap. The policy came second, as far as I can tell: if you voted “yes” in September then you couldn’t well go and vote a “unionist” party now, could you? Considering what the Labour party is meant to be, a party of the people and a party of all the people, identity politics obviously doesn’t sit well.

    Labour must steer clear of this identity nonsense. Jim Murphy shouting about another referendum clearly didn’t help the cause – not only were the SNP happy to make itself the only acceptable home of “yes” voters, but Labour were actively pushing them away. Let the SNP indulge in identity politics and nationalism but Labour should talk about substance, policy, inequality, aspiration. In the event of another referendum I think Labour should allow its membership and MSPs to come out on either side and not revisit a Better Together scenario. Given the numbers which voted “yes” across Scotland it is inconceievable to believe that the whole Labour family even believes in the Union and voted No.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s